There was a rare sighting off Pass-A-Grill beach in south Pinellas County this weekend. It’s creating a lot of excitement, but also debate over what exactly was photographed just offshore.

Scientists are taking a closer look at that video, and what appears to be a whale. One frame is interesting to scientists, showing what appears to be a white patch around the eye.

That’s why some believe it was an orca, but they are not able to say with 100% certainty.